Excerpted with permission from East to East: Recipes and Stories from Mumbai to New York
WRITER/RECIPE Rachel Gurjar
PHOTOGRAPHY Isa Zapata
I’ve been to a lot of dinner parties, but never once was I greeted by a glamorous, flowing fountain of cilantro-based, life-giving elixir. That changed at my first Gurjar Diwali. I learned the joy of cracking, stuffing, and shoving pani puri into my mouth—bursting with flavor and recalling memories of the cilantro from my grandma’s garden. And yes, “I now expect a pani puri fountain at every major celebration,” says my friend Zion.
The story goes like this: One year for my annual Diwali party, I repurposed a Champagne dispenser into a pani puri fountain because, frankly, I didn’t feel like standing around and serving each person individually. At one point during the party, friends were filling the crunchy fried puris with tequila, topping them with the highly addictive green water, and cheers-ing with pani puri shots. (“I want to bathe in this liquid,” Zion squealed.) As the night went on, people started pouring the water straight into cups to make cocktails. That’s definitely going in the book, I thought. And after a few delicious experiments, the Pani Puri Mezcalita was born. It’s smoky, tangy, a little spicy, and totally refreshing—basically everything I love about pani puri, my favorite street food, in cocktail form. The chaat masala-Tajìn rim hits you with that salty-sour punch before you even take a sip. It’s unexpected and way too good not to share.
Pani Puri Mezcalita
Serves 1 - 24
Active time: 15 minutes
INGREDIENTS FOR 1:
PANI PURI WATER
1 bunch cilantro (about 3 oz [85 g]), leaves and stems
1 bunch mint (about 2 oz [55 g]), leaves and tender stems
5 green Thai chiles or 1 serrano, stemmed
½ cup [120 ml] lime juice
1 tbsp plus 1 tsp chaat masala
2 tsp cumin seeds
1 tsp fine sea salt
1 tsp sugar
MEZCALITA
1 tbsp chaat masala, for garnish
1 tbsp Tajìn, for garnish (optional)
Lime wedge, for garnish
2 oz [60 ml] Pani Puri Water
1 ½ oz [45 ml] mezcal
1 oz [30 ml] lime juice
½ oz [15 ml] agave or maple syrup
¼ oz [7.5 ml] triple sec
Instructions for 1:
To make the pani puri water, to a blender or food processor, add the cilantro, mint, chiles, lime juice, chaat masala, cumin seeds, salt, and sugar. Pulse for a few seconds until the ingredients are pulverized into a smooth paste. Add 1 cup [240 ml] water and pulse one more time. Strain this mixture through a fine-mesh sieve, using the back of a ladle or spoon to push all the liquid through. Set the green liquid in the refrigerator to chill until ready to use. You will have extra pani puri water.
To make the mezcalita, to a small plate, add the chaat masala and Tajìn (if using) and mix to combine. Rub half the outer rim of an old fashioned or rocks glass with the lime wedge (reserve for serving), then roll the moistened rim in the chaat masala mix. Fill the glass with ice and set aside.
To a cocktail shaker or mason jar, add the pani puri water, mezcal, lime juice, agave syrup, and triple sec. Fill the shaker with ice, cover, and shake vigorously until the outside of the shaker is very cold, about 20 seconds. Strain into the prepared glass. Garnish with the reserved lime wedge and serve.
BATCH FOR 24:
PANI PURI WATER
6 bunches of cilantro (about 18 oz [510 g]), leaves and stems
6 bunches of mint (about 12 oz [340 g]), leaves and tender stems
30 green Thai chiles or 6 serranos, stemmed
3 cups [720 ml] lime juice
6 tbsp plus 2 tsp [65 g] chaat masala
¼ cup [30 g] cumin seeds
2 tbsp fine sea salt
2 tbsp granulated sugar
MEZCALITA
8 cups [1.9 L] Pani Puri Water
4 cups [945 ml] mezcal
4 cups [945 ml] lime juice
16 oz [475 ml] agave or maple syrup
8 oz [240 ml] triple sec
Chaat masala, for garnish
Tajìn, for garnish (optional)
Lime wedges, for garnish
Instructions for 24:
To make the pani puri water, to a blender or food processor, add the cilantro, mint, chiles, lime juice, chaat masala, cumin seeds, salt, and sugar. Pulse for a few seconds until the ingredients are pulverized into a smooth paste. Add 6 cups [1.4 L] water and pulse one more time. Strain this mixture through a fine-mesh sieve, using the back of a ladle or spoon to push all the liquid through. Set the green liquid in the refrigerator to chill until ready to use. You will have extra pani puri water.
To make the mezcalitas, in an extra large jug or pitcher, add the pani puri water, mezcal, lime juice, agave syrup, and triple sec. Use an immersion blender to blend all the ingredients together. Serve in ice-filled cocktail glasses rimmed with chaat masala and Tajìn (if using), and garnished with lime wedges. Or you could pour 6 oz [180 ml] into a cocktail shaker and shake with ice to make individual drinks.
Purchase your copy of East to East: Recipes and Stories from Mumbai to New York here.